Good fences make not make good neighbors, as New York Yankees superstar Derek Jeter faces off with a neighbor over the fence height around his massive Davis Islands property.
Deborah Ann “Debbie” Zomermaand is the 59-year-old treasurer of the Davis Islands Civic Association and vice president of Zomermaand Management Services. In 2006, Zomermaand and husband Randy purchased a $1.35-million, 4,608-square-foot Davis Islands home at 192 Corsica St. Four years later, the couple bought the home next door at 190 Corsica St.
Deborah sued Randy for divorce in October 2016; the case is currently in Hillsborough County court.
Jeter is the 42-year-old former All-Star player who played his entire professional career with the Yankees. In 2009, he built a 21,796-square-foot home at 58 Bahama Cir., which spans three lots on the Davis Islands waterfront. Jeter’s 7-bedroom, 9-bath house was recently appraised by the county at $11.9-million.
Jeter lives at the home with his wife, Hannah; the couple recently announced they are expecting a baby.
The Tampa Bay Times reports that the Tampa Variance Review Board approved Jeter’s request Jan. 10, allowing him to increase the height of the fence around his home to 8 feet and making the fencing opaque.
The variance is to help preserve the Jeter’s privacy and security. Attorney Brad Culpepper, the former Tampa Bay Buccaneers player who lives next door to Jeter, has supported the request.
Tampa Bay Times reporter Richard Danielson wrote about the height variance, citing intrusiveness and an increasing security risk, with “uninvited visitors get out of their cars to take photos, shoot video, lie down on the sidewalk, damage landscaping, antagonize neighborhood dogs and even fly drones.”
Debbie Zomermaand was the only person opposing the petition.
In a 156-page petition for Writ of Certiorari filed Feb. 6 in Hillsborough County Circuit Court, Debbie Zomermaand asks to overturn Jeter’s fence variance. She claims the Variance Review Board mistakenly concluded that she has no standing as an “aggrieved party” since she does not live within 250 feet of Jeter’s home.
Zomermaand also argues the Board exceeded its authority and Jeter’s situation does not actually meet the definition of “hardship.” Testimony by Jeter’s representatives, she adds, exaggerated the danger and inconvenience the Jeter family allegedly faces in the Davis Islands home.
This is not the first time Debbie Zomermaand has taken issue with what she considers an unusually tall fence. In 2013, Zomermaand sued over a property at 100 W. Davis Boulevard, claiming the Tampa City Council was wrong to allow the owner to build a 6-foot fence.