Patrick Murphy, Allen West trade blows in fight for CD 18

in Uncategorized by

Through TV or literature in their mailboxes, voters are getting to know U.S. Rep. Allen West as a teacher, an alleged “#1 enemy” for Medicare, an inner-city success story, a playground bully, a war hero, and even the tea party’s Mad Hatter of Alice in Wonderland fame.

Two of the country’s best-funded congressional campaigners — West and Democrat Patrick Murphy — are already hitting District 18 voters at home with clashing mailers and commercials. With the Aug. 14 primary two weeks away, the onslaught of pricey campaign communications is just getting started in the St. Lucie-Martin-Palm Beach district.

Several new Super PACs, committees not run by candidates that raise unlimited money generally used for slam ads, also could fuel millions more into the $12-million-plus contest.
The bottom line for voters — expect more mailbox clutter and TiVo commercial skip-overs through November.

“We’re going to get inundated with not just mailers, but television advertisements and targeted ads in a volume we’re not used to,” said Florida Atlantic University political science professor Kevin Wagner.

U.S. Rep. West, a Plantation Republican renting in Palm Beach Gardens, has racked up a $4.34 million bill this cycle just on direct mailers he’s sending nationwide. He has spent $490,000 on TV ads through June 30, and has $2.5 million more air time reserved through election season. With about $10 million raised across the country, however, West is one of few candidates who can afford spending $6.3 million total.

Former Democratic Treasure Coast U.S. Rep. Tim Mahoney said West’s controversial messages require big spending to reach his national audience.

“The bad news for Allen West is for every dollar he raises, he spends 80 cents because that’s what it costs,” Mahoney said. “The other thing he does is motivate centrist and left-wing groups to donate against him.”
West’s three TV ads paint him as a life-saving Army officer, a teacher — he spent nine months as a Broward County high school instructor — and an anti-Washington candidate who is “just getting started.” His mailers largely maintain the same messages, except for one four-pager calling his GOP primary competition Martin County Sheriff Robert Crowder his “liberal opponent.”

Murphy, a Fort Lauderdale accountant renting in Jupiter, has spent $990,000 of the $2.3 million he’s brought in. His campaign reported spending about $50,000 for three or four direct mailers, not including design costs lumped into $364,000 in consulting fees. Murphy has more than $460,000 in TV space reserved, and the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee has $656,000 and its Super PAC has $390,000 in West Palm Beach market TV time likely to be used for Murphy.

Murphy’s two TV spots depict West as a playground bully, and call Murphy a “builder, not a talker.” In one mailer, the Murphy campaign dressed up West like the Mad Hatter, gave him a teapot and asked voters to get an absentee ballot and “Stop Allen West’s Tea Party.” Another mailer has West holding a burning Medicare card, and it’s labeled “Medicare’s #1 Enemy.”

Former U.S. Rep. Mark Foley, a Republican who represented the Treasure Coast, said Murphy took the wrong approach as someone new to the area.

“When you’re trying to introduce yourself to voters, to make attack ads or whimsical, comical ads is less effective,” Foley said.

Crowder’s campaign, confined to a $64,000 budget, sent a two-sided mailer comparing himself to West. Stacy Ranieri, a campaign consultant, said the modest-sized piece cost $12,000 to send.

But Mahoney said he wouldn’t be surprised to see Crowder pull off an upset. Foley all but ruled out a Crowder win.

Palm City Democrat Jim Horn also got into the mailer mix with scathing criticisms of Murphy’s support through his family’s construction company.

In addition, big spending shows District 18 candidates are making the rounds nationally. West spent $45,500 to travel to fundraisers in New York, California, Atlanta, Tennessee, Texas, Arizona and more. The trips don’t stop there. He’s headed to Providence, R.I. and Syracuse, N.Y. next week to raise money for himself and other GOP players. At the Syracuse event, $1,000 gets you a ticket and a photo with West.

Murphy likewise has been to Washington, Arizona, Tennessee, Chicago, and elsewhere, tallying more than $11,000 in travel expenses.

The race also will soon be subject to groups that can accept unlimited contributions, upping the District 18 stakes even further.

The Super PAC “Dump West” formed earlier this month. Democratic strategist Andrew Perez said he formed the group in hopes of raising $5 million to oust West. Super PACs can’t coordinate with candidates themselves.
Murphy’s dad just donated $250,000 to the Super PAC “American Sunrise,” which lists only Murphy on its website as a “supported candidate.” Murphy’s father runs Coastal Construction Group and already is a large contributor to his son’s campaign.

“We only know what we’ve heard of that through newspapers,” said Anthony Kusich, Murphy campaign manager.

Another group has its sights set locally. “Treasure Coast Jobs Coalition” Super PAC was formed earlier this month  by New York/New Jersey attorney James Tyrrell III, who has written big checks to GOP presidential nominee Mitt Romney and other Republicans.

Wagner said Super PAC contributions could easily creep into the millions for the race.

“I actually believe Super PACs are going to make a much bigger difference in races like this, between West and Murphy, than in national elections where they’re getting the whole coverage,” Wagner said.

Peter Schorsch is the President of Extensive Enterprises and is the publisher of some of Florida’s most influential new media websites, including,,, and Sunburn, the morning read of what’s hot in Florida politics. SaintPetersBlog has for three years running been ranked by the Washington Post as the best state-based blog in Florida. In addition to his publishing efforts, Peter is a political consultant to several of the state’s largest governmental affairs and public relations firms. Peter lives in St. Petersburg with his wife, Michelle, and their daughter, Ella.