Perfect storm threatens oysters, and way of life, on North Florida bay

in Uncategorized by

Drought, a massive oil spill, a tropical storm and the state’s long-running water war with a neighboring state have combined to put the Florida Panhandle seafood industry in crisis, threatening the $6.6 million seafood industry – and for many people here, a way of life, reports Margie Menzel of the News Service of Florida.

The oyster harvest this year is historically bad, putting nearly half the Franklin County workforce at risk – 2,500 jobs, including the oystermen who work the bay, and related workers in the seafood houses lining the river and shoreline here.

The fate of the bay here – unlike so many others largely unspoiled by vacation development, could be hanging in the balance.

“It’s an all-hands-on-deck moment for this critically important community,” said Florida Agriculture Commissioner Adam Putnam. “This is not a short-term crisis.”

The main reason seems to be the drought affecting the upstream river basin. The Apalachicola River, which flows into the bay, comes south out of headwaters near Atlanta.

Freshwater flows to the bay arrive with a perfect mix of nutrients, diluting the salt of the sea and causing the oysters to thrive.

And oysters, in turn, are perfect little filters that help keep the bay clean – offering some protection to the seafood industry.

But Georgia has fought Florida and Alabama for more than 20 years to keep more water for the Atlanta area’s growing population. The three states have been locked in a legal battle over the river basin since 1990.

“We need help in getting someone to see that we have an equal ownership along the river,” said Anita Grove, executive director of the Apalachicola Bay Chamber of Commerce. “And that the person at the head of the river, because of unmitigated development, doesn’t own all the water…especially to the destruction of all the people at the lower end of the river.”

Putnam said the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers is keeping too much from flowing downstream.

“It is imperative that the Corps of Engineers release more water,” he said. “We have data that demonstrates that there have been worse droughts than what we’re in, but the flow has never been worse than it is today. And so, clearly, that is having an enormous impact on oyster populations.”

Those who make their living on the bay say it has sustained a series of blows, starting with the BP oil spill, which caused a rush to harvest, depleting the beds in 2010.

Franklin County Commissioner Joseph “Smokey” Parrish, whose day job is managing Buddy Ward Seafood and Sons, a shrimp processing plant, said part of the reason was that the oil spill shut down the oyster harvest in other states on the Gulf of Mexico.

“All the oyster bars from Apalachicola, all the way to Louisiana and Texas, needed oysters to serve the consumer,” he said. “So we harvested a lot more than what we should have during that time.”

The over-harvesting has continued, Parrish said, because the Gulf states still aren’t producing at anything close to their pre-oil spill levels.

“On top of that, we have a tropical storm, which is not even being recognized for the damage that it had it caused on top of our weakened beds,” said Shannon Hartsfield, president of the Franklin County Seafood Workers Association. Tropical Storm Debby tore through the area in June, churning up the oyster beds and disrupting their growth.

“Fifty-mile-an-hour winds for five days straight,” said Ricky Banks, of the county seafood workers group. “East winds right down the bay. So that’s put a devastation on our bay.”

Last month Gov. Rick Scott asked the federal government to declare the Apalachicola oyster harvesting area a fishery resource disaster area. In a Sept. 5 letter to Acting U.S. Commerce Secretary Rebecca Blank, he wrote: “This absence of freshwater contributes to higher salinity levels adversely affecting oyster populations and contributing to mass natural mortality events and a dramatic increase in oyster predation.”

Support is arriving in the form of food drives and help from charities with rent and utilities.

But for the oystermen and their families – often self-employed for five and six generations – such help, however necessary or kind, is hard to accept.

“We’re prideful. We are self-employed because we want to be self-employed,” said Hartsfield, a fourth-generation oysterman. “So having the guys come in and ask for a handout is hard…They’re still not coming in here yet.”

But when they realize there’s no more “product” in the bay, said Banks – whose children now make the sixth generation of his family to work for themselves – it may be a different story.

Scott’s request, if granted, would bring federal money in to further gauge the degree of decline, work on restoring the seafood population and provide economic assistance to the communities on the bay.

Four state agencies are involved: the state Departments of Agriculture, Children and Families and Economic Opportunity and the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission.

The Gulf Coast Workforce Board is setting up job retraining opportunities and temp work replenishing the bay. Among the latter options: a plan to pay unemployed oystermen to re-seed and re-shell the beds. That’s the process of covering the bay floor with old shells to encourage new growth in the oyster population. Also needed, said Hartsfield, is relaying – moving the oysters from closed areas to open ones.

“One, it helps start that recovery process,” said Dan Tonsmeire, executive director of Apalachicola Riverkeeper. “The other thing is: it helps the local workers. It puts them to work in a meaningful way that they can help pay their bills with.”

Local workforce officials are trying to get out-of-work seafood workers to take classes in other fields, like welding, health care jobs and golf course and resort work.

Some say the bay might have to be closed for as long as 12 to 18 months, which hasn’t happened since a series of hurricanes hit in 1985.

Putnam said the problem requires a complex response.

“Without additional fresh water coming down the Apalachicola River, we’re looking at a long-term problem that will require significant resources for long-term solutions,” said Putnam.

Scott said last week his administration has had no success so far in getting the Corps of Engineers to let more water downstream.

Local officials are hoping that temp work restoring the beds will enable people here to survive until the bay is replenished.

“That will put the people back to working for themselves, not depending on anyone else,” Banks said. “They would feel like they’re working for their money.”

Peter Schorsch is the President of Extensive Enterprises and is the publisher of some of Florida’s most influential new media websites, including,,, and Sunburn, the morning read of what’s hot in Florida politics. SaintPetersBlog has for three years running been ranked by the Washington Post as the best state-based blog in Florida. In addition to his publishing efforts, Peter is a political consultant to several of the state’s largest governmental affairs and public relations firms. Peter lives in St. Petersburg with his wife, Michelle, and their daughter, Ella.