Of all the Rays, who picked J.P. Arencibia to be a star?

On a night like this, when the stars align and the Rays play as if they are one of the best baseball teams in the American League, you can pick your stars. Do you want J.P. Arencibia, the kid from nowhere, fresh up from the minor leagues? Arencibia, a career .207 hitter, drove in six runs on a three-for-four night. Or do you want pitcher Drew Smyly, the guy coming back from injury, who struck out 10 and allowed only…