Republican Gov. Rick Scott’s campaign suggests in a new ad that former Gov. Charlie Crist has something to hide by not releasing his wife’s tax returns, while Crist said Wednesday that Scott is “hitting below the belt” by dragging his wife Carole into a negative campaign ad.
Scott last week released the joint tax return he filed with his wife Ann and called on Crist to do the same. The same day that Crist released tax returns for the three years since he left the governor’s office, the political committee working to re-elect Scott released a statewide ad criticizing Crist for not releasing his wife’s.
“It’s outrageous. It is hitting below the belt,” Crist said in a phone interview. “He has no honor, no decency. To drag my wife into a political ad is beyond the pale.”
Unlike the Scotts, the Crists file separate tax returns.
Crist’s Democratic primary rival, former Senate Democratic Leader Nan Rich, took his side on the issue. She said she isn’t releasing her tax return, which she filed jointly with her husband.
“I really don’t see why my husband, as a private citizen, should put his personal finances out there,” Rich said. “I feel the same way about Carole Crist as my husband – they’re private citizens. There’s no indication she’s done anything improper.”
But she said it is appropriate for Scott to release his wife’s finances because there are questions about whether he uses her trust fund or assets to hide his own income.
“When there’s suspicions, to make sure that the voters get the full information, there’s a reason to release that information,” Rich said in a phone interview. “There is a linkage here with Rick Scott and his wife because of how they handle their finances.”
The Scott ad also negatively refers to Crist as a millionaire, a status he only recently – and barely – achieved. Crist has a net worth of $1.2 million, less than the value of Scott’s $1.5 million vacation home, according to financial documents listing income and assets that both candidates are required to file.
Crist, now a Democrat, was never worth more than $1 million while serving as a Republican governor from 2007 to 2011.
Scott has a net worth of $133 million. His wife’s net worth has not been made public, but it’s clearly a lot. Her trust fund donated $12.8 million to Scott’s 2010 campaign.
While Carole Crist is also a millionaire, she made her fortune before meeting Crist and Crist said he isn’t involved in her business dealings.
Crist’s tax returns showed his adjusted gross income in the three years since leaving office ranged from $541,369 to $704,881.
Neither candidate is required to release his federal income tax returns, but Florida gubernatorial candidates have traditionally released theirs and their spouses’ returns. Whether governors and their challengers release tax returns varies from state to state, but the practice is voluntary. For example, Texas Gov. Rick Perry releases his, while California Gov. Jerry Brown doesn’t.
Scott said in a written statement released by his campaign that Carole Crist’s tax returns should also be released.
“Ann and I released both of our tax returns and we asked him and his wife to follow our lead. He is refusing. Alex Sink released her tax returns and her husband’s when she ran for governor. Jeb Bush and his wife released theirs,” Scott said. “The question we are all asking now is, what is Charlie hiding? I don’t think the people of Florida will let him get away with it.”
Whether the attack on Crist will resonate with voters is questionable, said Susan MacManus, a University of South Florida political science professor.
“In an era when so many women are independent and file separate from their husbands, this may not particularly play well with that constituency,” she said.
Republished with permission of the Associated Press.