Winners & losers emerging from Alex Sink’s decision not to run for Governor in 2014

in Uncategorized by

Imagine you are an NFL player whose team has made it deep into the playoffs. You have one game left — the conference championship — standing between you and playing in the Super Bowl.

Now imagine that your opponent in that conference championship match-up just decided it won’t be playing that game, meaning you’re on your way to the Super Bowl without having to face your toughest opponent to date.

That’s the scenario which just set itself up for Charlie Crist. Instead of having to face what would have been his toughest opponent, Alex Sink, he’s now on his way to the Super Bowl of Florida politics to face-off against Rick Scott. (Sorry, Nan Rich, you’re a wonderful Cinderella story, but you’ll be lucky to even make the playoffs under the scenario described above.)

This is such a huge deal in Crist-world, which had assumed the Sink would run in 2014, if for no other reason than out of spite for Crist. Or at least she would have taken so much time before deciding not to run that it would be as if she was in the race anyway.

Now, Crist has a clear shot at the Democratic nomination and, more important, a clear shot at the Democratic activists and fundraisers who would have remained loyal to Sink. Major players, like uber fundraiser Justin Day, are now free to sign up with Crist. In turn, national Democrats, like those at the Democratic Governors Association, are able to all but fully commit to Crist rather than having to wait more than a year for a primary to play out.

Make no mistake, Sink not running is the most important factor to date in Crist’s chances of success in 2014. The ramifications of Sink not running cannot be overstated.

That said, there are some clear winners and losers emerging from Sink’s decision not to run. Here’s a preliminary list.

Winners

Justin Day — Obama’s top bundler in Florida in 2012 would have been in a difficult spot had Sink decided to run. He was one of Sink’s top fundraisers in 2010 and would have been leaned on to raise money for Sink, despite Crist being The White House’s preferred choice. 

Danny Kanner –– The communications director for the Democratic Governors Association is emblematic of hundreds of Democratic operatives and activists who would have had to stay relatively neutral had Sink run (even though Kanner, as a former Crist spokesman, would have likely preferred Crist). Kanner and all of Obama- and Clinton-worlds are now free to look for short-term leases for apartments in Florida. 

John Morgan — Sink not running just saved the prominent trial lawyer and Crist patron, what, five million dollars? Ten million dollars? That’s what Morgan would have had to raise and/or spend out of his personal fortune to make sure Crist beat Sink in a primary. Now that same money can be spent defeating Scott.

Republican fundraisers — If your job is to raise money for Florida Republicans, is there anyone other than Charlie Crist you would want at the top of the ballot? After all, you can’t scare the base without a bogeyman. I imagine the direct mail shops are already at full bore pumping out fundraising letters. 

Nan Rich — The former Senate Minority Leader will receive forty percent of the vote in the Democratic primary just because she’s NOT Crist. The pressure on her to drop out of the race will be enormous by next Summer. Before that though, she gets to go one-on-one with Crist at every candidate forum and debate leading up to the election. She’ll probably be able to raise a few dollars, especially from Republicans, just to run a guerrilla campaign against Crist. 

Steve Schale — Nothing’s worse than when Daddy and Mommy fight. Fortunately for the Democratic Party’s favorite son in Florida, that’s no longer a possibility. Had Sink run, Schale would have been in the awkward position of having worked for the 2010 nominee, but not wanting to work for her in 2014. Now Schale is clear to get Crist up-and-running and, perhaps more difficult, introduced to full-on Democratic Party politics.

Alex Sink – By not running, Sink does not have to worry about her own political future and can just be the free-wheeling, fun-loving Sink we only catch glimpse.  Of late, Sink has been an effective, perhaps the most effective, critic of Scott on the economy. One of the last things Scott needs is a free-wheeling and well-respected Alex Sink traveling the state with nothing but time on her hands to deconstruct his economic argument. 

Tallahassee lobbyists — Here’s the pitch I would make to my clients if I were Ballard Capitol Floridian Gray Southern Partners or any other lobbyist plying my craft in Tallahassee: ‘We better get ‘X’ done this year because who knows what the capital will look like in 2015. Send money’ 

Losers

Florida’s Republican lawmakers — As much as Crisafulli-Corcoran-Oliva-Gardiner-Thrasher-Negron-Latvala downright despise Crist, none of them doubt his political capabilities. So if Crist’s chances of winning in 2014 were 40% on Thursday, they have to be better than even with Sink out of the picture. If you are a Republican lawmaker who will be in leadership come 2015, you’re now facing the distinct possibility of not having an ally in the Governor’s office for the first time in sixteen years. 

Florida’s TV stations — A competitive primary between Crist and Sink would have meant millions of dollars in advertising dollars for the state’s seemingly unending number of media markets. Crist will still spend some money to defeat Rich and the Republicans will still spend money to discredit Crist, but there won’t be eight figures worth of TV ad time like there would have been had Crist and Sink faced-off.

Lenny Curry — The chairman of the Republican Party of Florida may be the biggest loser AND winner emerging from Sink’s decision. On one hand, Curry and Co. lose out because they don’t have a legitimate vehicle to attack Crist as they would have had had Sink run. Meanwhile, the RPOF’s reverse-psychology line of attacks involving Nan Rich are increasingly played out. On the other hand, Curry is gonna get what he says he’s wanted all along — a clear shot at Crist. Let’s see what happens when the dog catches the bumper. 

Tony Fabrizio — During a recent public appearance, Scott’s adviser and pollster practically begged Crist to enter the race and insinuated that the party-changing former governor may not make it past his new party’s primary. By a show of hands, who thinks that Rich — even with the help of what Fabrizio called “outside intervention” — can overtake Charlie? That’s what I thought.

Patrick Manteiga — The publisher of La Gaceta was Sink’s biggest cheerleader in the media; in fact, it was rare when the issue of Sink running or not running DID NOT make its way into Manteiga’s weekly column. The fierce Democrat now faces a Sophie’s choice of supporting Crist or Rich … or sitting out the race entirely.

Bill Nelson — Conventional wisdom held that Sink would not make her decision until after Nelson unequivocally stated he was not running for Governor in 2014. Sink’s announcement has kind of forced Nelson’s hand, leaving him only two options: support Crist (which he actually wants to do) or run himself.   

Rick Scott — By not having a real primary, Crist can avoid having to get into a who-is-more-of-a-Democrat fight and instead run as Charlie Crist in the space he relishes occupying: the populist middle.  This makes it much harder for Scott to box his way into the center with the kind of independents needed to win — and if Scott can’t get to 50% among these centrist voters, his path is nearly impossible. The current debate about Common Core is a perfect example of this scenario.

Peter Schorsch is the President of Extensive Enterprises and is the publisher of some of Florida’s most influential new media websites, including SaintPetersBlog.com, FloridaPolitics.com, ContextFlorida.com, and Sunburn, the morning read of what’s hot in Florida politics. SaintPetersBlog has for three years running been ranked by the Washington Post as the best state-based blog in Florida. In addition to his publishing efforts, Peter is a political consultant to several of the state’s largest governmental affairs and public relations firms. Peter lives in St. Petersburg with his wife, Michelle, and their daughter, Ella.