Life and politics from the Sunshine State's best city

For once, Peyton Manning is being compared with worst QBs

in Sports/Top Headlines by

Just like that, and Denver’s Peyton Manning is on the wrong side of the room.

For most of his career, he has been among the most celebrated of quarterbacks. He has the nifty nickname, “The Sheriff.” He has all the records. He has so many comebacks.

And now, in what may be his final game, he is just another guy. That, as much as anything, provides the intrigue for Sunday’s Super Bowl game against Carolina.

Forever, the comparisons to Manning have been lofty. He has been compared to Tom Brady, to Johnny Unitas, to the best the game has to offer. But these days, coming off what statistically was his worst season, Manning is being compared to the less impressive quarterbacks the Super Bowl has had to offer. It’s a sober realization, one that still doesn’t seem right.

Injuries and age have been taking away from Manning, though. He no longer seems to have the zip on the ball. He no longer can wedge it into tight spaces.

He has won only seven games. He has nine touchdown passes to 17 interceptions. He has a rating in the 60s. Those are the numbers you might expect from Trent Dilfer, or from Vince Ferragamo, or from Rex Grossman.

Still, there is a chance.

Len Dawson found one. You might not remember, but Dawson had a brutal season before winning Super Bowl V. He was only 5-2, and he threw nine touchdowns to 13 interceptions. Yet, he led the Chiefs to a victory.

Joe Namath, for all his bravado, wasn’t very good in 1969. He completed less than 50 percent of his passes, and he threw more interceptions than touchdowns. But he won one of the most memorable Super Bowls in history against the Colts.

Terry Bradshaw, before he was immortal, was just another guy. He was 5-2 in 1974 and his rating was only 55.2. He threw for only 96 yards in the Steelers’ victory over Minnesota. But he would lead Pittsburgh to four straight titles.

Jeff Hostetler had only two career wins before 1990, when he led the Giants past the favored Bills. Dilfer has been called the worst quarterback ever to win a Super Bowl, but win it he did. Doug Williams didn’t have a win as a starting quarterback (he won three off the bench) for the Redskins before going 3-0 in 1987 and winning MVP honors.

And so it goes.

So who were the worst of the Super Bowl quarterbacks? Well, Rex Grossman had a rating of only 39.3 the year his Bears made it. Ferragamo was at a 49 rating and won only four times during the season.

Here’s the thing, though: with the rule changes, with free agency, with more competitive games, the quarterback has become more and more important for a Super Bowl team. Run-of-the-mill quarterbacks such as Kerry Collins or Mark Rypien don’t make it much anymore.

So, yeah, there is pressure on Manning to play well on Sunday. It’s hard to envision the Broncos winning otherwise.

One last dose of magic.

Does Manning have it in him?

Gary Shelton is one of the most recognized and honored sportswriters in the history of the state. He has won the APSE's national columnist of the year twice and finished in the top 10 eight times. He was named the Florida Sportswriter of the Year six times. Gary joined SaintPetersBlog in the spring, helping to bring a sports presence to the website. Over his time in sports writing, Gary has covered 29 Super Bowls, 10 Olympics, Final Fours, Masters, Wimbledons and college national championships. He was there when the Bucs won a Super Bowl, when the Lightning won a Stanley Cup and when the Rays went to a World Series. He has seen Florida, FSU and Miami all win national championships, and he covered Bear Bryant, Bobby Bowden and Don Shula along the way. He and his wife Janet have four children: Eric, Kevin, K.C. and Tori. To contact, visit

Latest from Sports

Go to Top